Comparison

Compare Mimecast vs Proofpoint Essentials

See this comparison of Mimecast vs Proofpoint Essentials. Mimecast rates 4.5/5 stars. Proofpoint Essentials rates 4.3/5 stars.

Snapshot

Mimecast blocks malware, spam and zero-day attacks.

Snapshot

Proofpoint Essentials is designed for MSPs to protect their customers from spam, viruses and data loss.

For

Enterprise organizations that need strong, reliable protection from spam with an integrated archiving solution.

For

Small and Midsized organizations looking for strong email protection with optional archiving and compliance at cost effective pricing.

Who are Mimecast

Mimecast is one of the largest global email cyber security vendors. They have a large suite of cloud based security applications to protect organisations from email and web based security threats. Their Email Security product is aimed at enterprise level customers. It utilizes multiple detection engines to provide protection from phishing, malware, spam and zero day attacks. This platform is a Secure Email Gateway, meaning it blocks potentially dangerous emails before they enter your network.

What is Proofpoint Essentials?

Proofpoint is a cyber security vendor what protects organizations against advanced threats and data loss. They offer cloud based security solutions to help you detect and block targeted attacks. Proofpoint Essentials is an all in one email security solution. It offers email protection at the gateway, which stops threats from entering your email network. It also offers Continuity, Management and encryption and archiving as additional modules. Proofpoint Essentials is aimed at small to midsized organizations and is sold through resellers and MSPs.

Profile: Mimecast

Category:
Email Security Gateway
Website:
mimecast.com
Founded:
2003
Headquartered:
Boston, MA, US
Deployment:
Cloud, MX Record Redirection
Starting Price:
$8 user / month
Suitable For:
Enterprise

Profile: Proofpoint Essentials

Category:
Email Security Gateway
Website:
proofpoint.com
Founded:
2002
Headquartered:
Sunnyvale, CA, US
Deployment:
Cloud, MX Record Redirection
Starting Price:
$1.50 to $5.33 user/month, 4 different versions
Suitable For:
Designed for MSPs

Mimecast Features:

  • Impersonation Protection blocks phishing attempts and spam
  • Popular email service, with high levels of customer satisfaction
  • High – level threat protection features including attachment sandboxing and URL protection
  • Large threat database monitoring billions of emails ensures that threat protection is up to date
  • Robust spam filtering, with guaranteed 99% spam rate detection
  • Comprehensive real time reports over your email network, including all inbound and outbound traffic
  • Self-service tools for end users, such as allowing them to block senders
  • Fully featured but easy to administer service, offering a web based dashboard from which all policies are managed
  • Email Continuity available if the email network goes down, with 100% service availability SLA
  • Includes an Email Archiving option, as well as secure messaging and large file sending

Features of Proofpoint Essential?

  • Enhanced email security with signature based anti-virus and phishing protection
  • Strong threat protection with content filtering, outbound filtering and attachment defence
  • Continuity is included with the core service, with archiving and encryption available as add-ons
  • URL and attachment defence helps to block email threats from entering networks.
  • Advanced and Pro modules contain social media account protection to help businesses who have been hacked on social media
  • Comprehensive reports and logs give businesses more control and awareness of their email security
  • Management features include multi-level logins, domain management and active directory integration mean this service is easy to administer
  • Robust filter rules engine means admins can control email security settings

Expert Insight

Mimecast offers a market leading Email Security platform. This platform works as a secure gateway, meaning that it blocks threats before they enter an email network. This is a very robust service, which offers a range of advanced features that will help businesses to secure themselves against email threats. This is platform offers strong protection against malware, spam and zero-day attacks. It offers real time malware defence and attachment sandboxing. Spam filtering is strong, with Mimecast offering an SLA on 99% of spam blocked. Mimecast offers a range of logs to give you real time visibility over your email network. With this platform administrators have fine-grade control over all levels of email security. End users also get controls to block senders, helping to reduce the burden on IT. Email Archiving, and Continuity and Large File Sending can be purchased as add-ons.

This platform is very popular among customers, with high levels of customer satisfaction and retention. The service is expensive and so is more suitable for larger enterprises who need the strongest level of email protection. However, the adage of ‘you get what you pay for’ rings true with Mimecast Email Security, as it is one of the strongest, fully featured email security platforms available. Organizations with a big security budget, looking for the strongest protection they can get, should consider this service.

Potential customers should note that Expert Insights has seen a trend of existing Mimecast customers researching alternative phishing protection solutions to protect against phishing attacks.

Expert Insight:

Proofpoint Essentials is a strong solution for email protection, encryption, archiving and continuity as a single platform. Proofpoint has excellent security research, which ensure that this platform offers a high level of threat protection. Spam filtering is also robust. The platform has a good range of management features, and is cost effective, with many features such as Continuity included in the core service, whereas it is normally a bolt-on purchase. There are also a good range of reports and logs to give you more control and awareness over your email network.

Proofpoint Essentials have had system stability issues in the past, partly caused by a large growth in the user base of the service. However, it appears that these issues have now been fully resolved. The administrator console, while being fully featured could be modernized to improve ease of use.

Expert Insights suggest that organizations requiring robust protection from email threats use a secure email gateway in conjunction with a separate post delivery protection solution to ensure robust protection from phishing attacks.